| Sis. Olive Adderley | 1st President | 1938 |
| Sis. Naomi Cox | 2nd President | |
| Sis. Sybil Backford | 3rd President | |
| Dr. Majorie Francis | 4th President | 1976 |
| Sis. Miriam Roker | 5th President | 1977 – 1992 |
| Sis. Rachel Ferguson | 6th President | 1992 – 1996 |
| Sis. Dorothy Laing | 7th President | 1996 – 2005 |
| Sis. Helen Ferguson | 8th President | 2005 – 2017 |
| Min. Lydia Musgrove-Rolle | 9th President | 2017 – Present |